CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR TAX & FINANCIAL PROFESSIONALS
Subscribe
Login
Main Menu
Main Menu
Account
Cart

The ACA Enhanced Subsidy Expires

By

The enhanced Affordable Care Act premium tax credits expired December 31, 2025, creating immediate revenue recognition and tax planning challenges for approximately 22 million taxpayers.

Technical Background: What Actually Expired

The underlying IRC §36B premium tax credit structure remains intact. What expired were the temporary enhancements under American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) of 2021, extended through December 31, 2025, by the Inflation Reduction Act:

Enhanced Provisions That Expired:

  • Elimination of the 400% FPL cliff for subsidy eligibility
  • Premium cap reduction from 9.83% to 8.5% of household income for benchmark coverage
  • Increased applicable percentage tables providing more generous subsidies across all income bands
  • Zero-premium bronze plans for households at 100-150% FPL

What Remains:

  • Base IRC §36B premium tax credits for households between 100-400% FPL
  • Subsidy calculation methodology based on benchmark Silver plan
  • Form 8962 reconciliation requirements
  • Advance payment and repayment limitation structures

The Numbers: KFF Analysis

Kaiser Family Foundation analysis projects average annual net premiums for subsidized enrollees increasing from $888 in 2025 to $1,904 in 2026—a 114% increase. However, this understates impact for specific cohorts:

  • Age 60-64 enrollees: Premium increases of 150-200% common due to age-rating
  • Households at 401-600% FPL: Complete loss of subsidy eligibility
  • Geographic variation: States with higher underlying premium costs seeing disproportionate impact

State-Level Impact Analysis

The geographic concentration of affected taxpayers creates regional planning considerations:

Highest Enrollment States (KFF data):

  • Florida: 4.7+ million enrollees—largest exposure of any state
  • Texas: 3.9+ million enrollees
  • California: Substantial enrollment but state subsidies may partially offset
  • Georgia: Significant enrollment with limited state-level relief options
  • North Carolina: High enrollment concentration

Florida practitioners should expect particularly high client volume on this issue given enrollment concentration and absence of state subsidy programs. Texas advisors face similar dynamics.

Tax Planning Implications for 2026

Q1 2026 Priority Actions:

Form 8962 Reconciliation (2025 Returns):

  • Verify accuracy of 2025 advance premium tax credit calculations
  • Confirm household income estimates matched actual for subsidy recipients
  • Calculate repayment obligations if MAGI exceeded projections
  • Review repayment limitation eligibility for households under 400% FPL

2026 Estimated Tax Adjustments:

  • Clients losing enhanced subsidies may have significant cash flow disruption requiring quarterly estimate recalculation
  • Medical expense deduction threshold (7.5% AGI floor) newly achievable for many clients
  • Consider Safe Harbor implications if client income volatility expected

MAGI Management Strategies:

For clients near 400% FPL threshold, income management is important:

  • Traditional IRA contributions: $7,000 ($8,000 age 50+) MAGI reduction
  • HSA contributions: If switching to HDHP, $4,300 single/$8,550 family (age 55+ catch-up $1,000)
  • Roth conversion suspensions: Pause conversions if pushing client over 400% FPL cliff
  • Capital gain harvesting/deferral: Manage MAGI in subsidy eligibility years
  • Business owner strategies: Retirement plan contribution optimization, equipment purchases under §179 and bonus depreciation

Alternative Structure Considerations:

  • COBRA analysis: May be economically viable now compared to unsubsidized marketplace—run the numbers
  • Spouse employment evaluation: Whether return to workforce for employer coverage outweighs childcare costs/other factors
  • Qualified Small Employer HRA (QSHRA): For small business owner clients, individual coverage HRA structures merit fresh analysis

Medical Expense Deduction Planning

Higher health insurance premium outlays push many clients over 7.5% of AGI threshold for first time:

Action Items:

  • Collect all qualified medical expenses (insurance premiums, unreimbursed care, prescriptions, mileage)
  • Consider bunching elective procedures into 2026 to maximize deduction

Real-World Impact:

My sister and her husband—both in their early 60s—represent the population hit hardest by this expiration. Managing pre-existing conditions (COPD and diabetes), they had been paying $1,800 monthly for marketplace coverage after premium tax credits in 2025. Their 2026 renewal notification showed $2,800 monthly with zero subsidy eligibility—a $12,000 annual increase representing complete loss of federal assistance.

With fixed retirement income and no viable alternatives until Medicare eligibility, they face impossible choices: liquidate retirement assets prematurely, or risk coverage gaps while managing serious chronic conditions. This isn’t theoretical policy analysis—it’s family dealing with a $12,000 hole in their budget overnight.

Practitioners should expect similar scenarios across your client base, particularly among early retirees with pre-existing conditions. A few tax planning strategies may provide a lifelines for clients or family members in these situations.

High-Net-Worth Client Considerations

For clients above 400% FPL who lost all subsidy eligibility:

  • Cash flow impact: $15,000-$30,000+ annual increase will be common for older couples
  • Medicare planning acceleration: Some clients may find the cash to pay extra premiums by opting for early Social Security at 62, despite permanently reduced benefits
  • Roth conversion opportunity: Since losing subsidy anyway, MAGI increases from Roth conversions no longer create subsidy loss (tax planning silver lining)

Legislative Outlook and Client Communication

House expected to vote on three-year extension in early January 2026, but Senate passage uncertain. Key messaging points for clients:

  • Don’t make irreversible decisions immediately: Coverage dropped now cannot be re-enrolled until 2027 open enrollment absent qualifying event or legislative
  • Monitor legislative developments: Retroactive reinstatement is possible if bill passes
  • Explore all marketplace options: Bronze and silver plans with cost-sharing reductions may pencil out better than assumed

Practice Management Notes

Expect client contact in Q1 2026 as renewal notices arrive and bills come due. Consider:

  • Client advisory emails explaining situation
  • Referral relationships with health insurance brokers for technical marketplace questions
  • Standard engagement letter provisions for legislative uncertainty

Conclusion

The enhanced subsidy expiration represents significant planning disruption affecting 22+ million taxpayers. Early retirees with pre-existing conditions—like my sister and brother-in-law who saw net premiums jump $12,000 annually—face particularly acute challenges that no amount of tax planning can fully solve.

This article provides general information for tax practitioners. Individual client situations require specific analysis. Consult IRC §36B, Form 8962 instructions, and current IRS guidance for technical details.

Recent Stories

Next Up...

IRS Premium Tax Credit FAQ Update: What to Know for 2026

With unlimited repayment starting 2026, the IRS FAQ provides guidance on Form 1095-A reconciliation, shared
4 min read

The Best CPE for Accountants in 2026

Looking for the best CPE for CPAs in 2026? We've got you covered with a
6 min read

The IRS Issues Relief for Farmland Sales Under New Section 1062

The IRS issued Notice 2026-3 on December 22nd, waiving estimated tax penalties that would have
5 min read