CONTINUING EDUCATION FOR TAX & FINANCIAL PROFESSIONALS

BLACK FRIDAY SALE: Save on conferences, the Federal Tax Update, credit packages, and more — ends Nov 27.

A health care staffing agency has lost a $202,925 employee retention credit (ERC) refund suit for the third quarter of 2021. In Southern Arizona Health Services Phoenix, LLC v. United States, the Court of Federal Claims granted the government’s cross-motion for summary judgment, holding that federal workplace safety requirements did not suspend the agency’s operations. The agency kept supplying nurses to its clients throughout the quarter.

The decision is trial-court authority and may be appealed to the Federal Circuit. It nevertheless adds to a consistent line of cases: an order that makes work harder, more expensive, or less convenient does not, without more, cause a full or partial suspension of operations for ERC purposes.

The Facts

The agency filed its third quarter 2021 Form 941 without claiming the credit, then filed Form 941-X on November 28, 2022. The IRS never acted on the claim, and the agency sued for refund on January 14, 2025. The agency relied only on the suspension test of §3134(c)(2)(A)(ii)(I), not the gross receipts test. It pointed to the OSHA COVID-19 Healthcare Emergency Temporary Standard, 29 C.F.R. §1910.502, including its requirement to remove COVID-positive and exposed workers, and to safety protocols imposed by the host facilities where its nurses worked.

The Court's Reasoning

The court required the agency to show a qualifying governmental order, a full or partial suspension of its trade or business, and a causal link between the two. Because the statute requires a suspension “due to” the order, the order had to be both the but-for and the proximate cause of the suspension. A partial suspension requires that a discrete, more-than-nominal portion of the business cease during the quarter.

The agency could not meet that standard. An order that sets conditions under which the same activity continues does not limit commerce, and excluding infected or exposed workers did not suspend the business. The record showed the administrative office stayed open, in-person interviews continued, and nurse staffing continued without interruption. Because the agency billed clients per twelve-hour shift rather than per patient, fewer patients per shift had no economic effect, and it billed additional hours when clients requested them.

Example: Two Employers, Two Results

Dana owns a home health staffing firm and claimed the ERC for the second quarter of 2021 based on masking, screening, and distancing rules. Her caregivers kept working their scheduled visits. Under the reasoning in Southern Arizona Health Services, Dana’s file shows higher compliance costs, not a suspended operation, and her claim is vulnerable.

Leo owns a restaurant subject to a state order that closed indoor dining for six weeks in the fourth quarter of 2020, while takeout continued. Indoor dining produced 55% of his gross receipts before the order. A discrete portion of his business stopped because of the order, and it easily exceeds the 10% of gross receipts benchmark Notice 2021-20 uses to measure whether a portion is more than nominal. Leo still needs records proving the order, the closure dates, and the revenue split, but his claim rests on an operation that actually ceased.

Why Safety-Protocol Claims are Vulnerable

Many ERC claims were built on generic narratives about PPE purchases, workspace modifications, screening, staggered schedules, and capacity rules. Those facts show compliance costs. They do not identify an operation that stopped. A defensible suspension claim ordinarily needs evidence of four elements:

  1. A governmental order that actually applied to the employer, its location, or a critical supplier.
  2. A specific business operation that the order prohibited or required the employer to stop.
  3. Proof that the affected operation was more than nominal.
  4. A direct causal connection between the order and the cessation during the claimed quarter.

A file that proves only the first element is incomplete. A file that proves operational difficulty but no cessation is equally exposed.

Open Questions

The court did not hold that safety rules can never contribute to a qualifying suspension, and other courts may weigh partial-suspension facts differently. Whether the agency appeals, and how the Federal Circuit treats the “more-than-nominal” and proximate cause standards, will matter for pending litigation.

Tax Practitioner Planning

The next step depends on the claim’s posture: unprocessed, under examination, disallowed, in Appeals, or in refund litigation. A taxpayer considering suit should expect discovery and summary judgment to test the narrative against contemporaneous records, as happened here. For a claim that rests on safety protocols alone, discuss the risks of continuing with the client and document that conversation.

Action Items

  1. Identify the exact order, issuing authority, effective dates, geographic reach, and mandatory language.
  2. Describe the employer’s normal operations before the order and the operation that actually stopped because of it.
  3. Quantify the affected operation with contemporaneous revenue, service hours, employee hours, output, or capacity data.
  4. Separate the order’s effect from labor shortages, voluntary safety measures, reduced demand, illness, and supply-chain problems.
  5. Confirm that the claimed quarter matches the period in which the order caused the suspension.
  6. Preserve schedules, contracts, cancellation records, operating reports, and communications rather than relying on a later narrative.

Recent Stories

Next Up...

A 10-year marriage can unlock Social Security on a former spouse’s record. Learn the rules
7 min read
T.D. 10053 says payment platforms backup withhold only after a seller tops $20,000 and 200
2 min read
A 10-year marriage can unlock Social Security on a former spouse’s record. Learn the rules
6 min read